| MOST stumpings | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| NO | PLAYER | total stumpings | YEARS ACTIVE |
| 1. | Malcolm L. Paech | 49 | 1953 – 1972, 1978 |
| 2. | Wayne A. Willis | 30 | 1993 – 2008, 2012 – 2017 |
| 3. | Matthew L. Hutchinson | 19 | 1997 – 2021 |
| 4. | M.J. “Pickle” Paech | 14 | 1988 – Present |
| T5. | Ken Patterson | 13 | 1964 – 1972 |
| T5. | Brian Sasche | 13 | 1986 – 1994 |
| T5. | Matthew J. Johns | 13 | 2008 – 2011, 2014 – 2015 |
| 8. | John Mahomet | 10 | 1975 – 1983, 1986 |
| T9. | Jaxon Lynn | 7 | 2022 – Present |
| T9. | Brian F. Blight | 7 | 1938 – 1940, 1946 – 1975 |
| T9. | J.H. “Nipper” Klaebsch | 7 | 1934 – 1940, 1946 – 1947, 1962 – 1963 |
| T12. | Jason Rehn | 6 | 2021 – Present |
| T12. | Elliot Pryor | 6 | 2009 – 2014, 2017 |
| T12. | J. Saltmarsh | 6 | 1954 – 1955 |
